Last month, it was announced that, following a Government consultation, the Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993 (‘the Regulations’) would continue to apply in the UK.
In this article, our Dispute Resolution Lawyers, examine the purpose of the Regulations, the nature of the consultation, and the impact of the decision to retain the Regulations.
The Regulations
The Regulations derive from EU law and have been applied in the UK for over 30 years.
Fundamentally, they protect agents in areas including termination and compensation.
In particular, the Regulations offer:
- Compensation or an indemnity payable upon an agency contract’s termination, even in the absence of a written contractual entitlement or if the contract attempts to exclude such protection;
- Minimum notice periods when terminating agreements;
- Protection against unfair contract terms; and
- Terms which are implied into agency contracts automatically.
The Consultation
The introduction of the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act in 2023 afforded ministers a greater ability to replace or revoke EU laws that had been retained following Brexit. This sparked a consultation on whether the Regulations were required and worthwhile in the UK.
The consultation saw the Government reach out to agents and principals from a variety of businesses, alongside lawyers, academics and other informed parties. Interestingly, approximately 70% of the 86 respondents were commercial agents, whilst only 8% were principals.
The consultation evaluated the extent to which respondents comprehended the Regulations’ impact, the importance of the Regulations’ protections, and the impact that deregulation would have on the ability for agents and principals to contract and the frequency of disputes between the two parties.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, there was a contrast between the views of agents and principals.
Agents feared deregulation, believing such a step may lead to legal uncertainty and reduced financial protections for their businesses.
Principals, meanwhile, deemed the Regulations to be strongly in favour of agents, resulting in an unequal relationship that makes it challenging to negotiate fair terms, terminate for breach or avoid providing compensation or an indemnity.
The Impact
On 13 February 2025, the Government published its response to the consultation.
It was decided that the Regulations would be retained, with the Department for Business and Trade stating that the feedback showed they ‘work well for commercial agents’ and ‘were well understood by respondents’. Indeed, the Government response cited the fact that principals are often larger businesses than commercial agents when referring to the protections the Regulations afford to the latter.
As a consequence, legal certainty will remain in place in principal-agent relationships, as will the various protections afforded to agents. In turn, the decision may have saved future time negotiating and disputing matters between parties.
Though some principals may be disappointed by the decision, agents may well have demanded greater commission or compensation had the Regulations been revoked.
Ultimately, regardless of one’s opinion on the decision, the Regulations are here to stay and must continue to be applied in commercial agency contracts.
Contact Our Dispute Resolution Solicitors
If you would like assistance with your agency contract or advice on the Regulations, contact our Dispute Resolution Solicitors.
01619414000
Latest Myerson Dispute Resolution News
Myerson Secures Substantial Settlement for Commercial Agent
Myerson Solicitors' Commercial Agency specialists are pleased to have secured a substantial settlement for a commercial agent operating in the lighting controls and building technology sector following the termination of a long-standing agency relationship with a UK supplier.
Read Blog
28
Restrictive Covenants: Managing Risks When Key Employees Move On
Leaving a business or facing the departure of a key employee? Learn the risks, rights and remedies in restrictive covenant disputes. When a senior employee leaves, both the individual and the business can face difficult questions about restrictive covenants, client relationships and post-termination obligations.
View Event
Myerson Secures Construction Adjudication Success on Major MOD Infrastructure Project
Myerson's Commercial Litigation team has successfully acted for a leading provider of professional infrastructure and managed network services in an adjudication arising from a payment dispute with another contractor on a major Ministry of Defence infrastructure project . David Jones and James Griffiths of the Commercial Litigation team led the...
Read Blog
Myerson Successfully Defends Grounds Maintenance Contractor in High Court Restrictive Covenant Injunction Case
Myerson Solicitors is pleased to have successfully defended a grounds maintenance sub-contractor in a restrictive covenant dispute in London, securing a favourable outcome and achieving a significant recovery of the client’s legal costs. The matter was led by David Jones , with support from Kit Bevan of Myerson's Commercial Litigation team, who...
Read Blog
Vesting Order Success: Recovering £600,000 of Bona Vacantia Property from the Crown
Myerson’s David Jones and Amna Iqbal recently acted for a client in a complex matter involving two valuable investment properties worth in the region of £600,000. The properties had unintentionally vested in the Crown as bona vacantia following the strike‑off and dissolution of the client’s company due to the negligence of their former...
Read Blog