Call +44(0)161 941 4000
Call +44(0)161 941 4000
This note aims to serve as a practical guide to Defendants who find themselves facing allegations of trademark infringement.
A trademark is a symbol, word or words used by a trader to distinguish its products or services from those of others. A trademark protects branding for businesses including product names, logos, acronyms, slogans, trading styles and even colours. Trademarks are a very valuable form of IP because they become associated with quality and consumer expectations in a product or service. It is therefore vital for businesses to identify, register and protect their trademark(s).
Trademark owners can apply for a Community trademark (CTM) or a UK trademark. A UK registered trademark is only enforceable in the UK, whereas a CTM is enforceable throughout the EU. Each type of registration lasts ten years and is renewable for further ten-year periods. It is also possible to register trademarks throughout the world, although it is advisable to initially register them in the countries where the goods or services are to be supplied.
To be registrable, a trademark must be distinctive, capable of being represented graphically, capable of distinguishing goods or services and not be excluded by statute.
The law relating to UK registered trademarks is contained primarily in the Trade Marks Act 1994 (TMA) which implemented the 2008 Trade Marks Directive and its successor the 2015 Trade Marks Directive. The law relating to CTMs is contained in the EUTM Regulations 2017.
Broadly, trademark infringement occurs when someone else uses a sign that is identical to a registered trademark in the course of a trade. The TMA goes further to state that even if a sign is similar to that of a registered trademark, this could be classed as an infringement if it creates confusion in the minds of the public. Therefore, a Defendant will not escape liability for trademark infringement by simply altering the wording or logo of a registered trademark.
The infringer must have also used the infringing mark in the course of trade.
Trademarks can still be enforced even if they have not been registered. This is through the common law action of passing off. The underlying principle behind this action is that “a man is not to sell his goods under the pretence that they are the goods of another man”. Broadly speaking, passing off occurs when:
The benchmark for establishing passing off is normally higher than for trademark infringement as the claimant must prove goodwill, misrepresentation and damage. In an action for trademark infringement, if one of the prohibited acts set out above has been committed, a defendant is likely to be liable unless they successfully plead one of the statutory defences.
Commonly, if there is a registered trademark, a claim is likely to be brought for both trademark infringement and passing off. This is particularly so if there are grounds for a defendant to challenge the validity of the registered trademark.
There are defences to trademark infringement such as:
In addition, there may be further defences relating to exhaustion of rights in relation to goods put on the market in the EU. The principle is that a trademark holder that has put goods for sale in the EU cannot then interfere with any subsequent commercialisation or re-sale of the goods in question.
Finally, Section 21 of the TMA and the Intellectual Property (Unjustified Threats) Act 2017 provide remedies against groundless threats of infringement proceedings. These pieces of legislation are intended to protect secondary infringers, such as manufacturers or importers, from groundless threats made by trademark holders. The legislation clarifies what can be send in correspondence with alleged infringers and allow limited communications with secondary infringers. We would always recommend obtaining specialist legal advice as to what would and would not constitute groundless threats.
Prevention is always better than the cure as defending trademark infringement proceedings can be costly in terms of legal fees, potential damages and in lost management time.
If you are creating a sign or a brand, make sure that it is not already registered. A simple search on Google or on the Intellectual Property Office (IPO) website may reveal that a sign is already registered. For a more sophisticated search, you should seek advice from a Trademark Attorney. We have excellent relationships with a number of Trademark Attorneys who we can refer you to if you need their advice.
Taking an assignment or licence of third party marks, where possible, is an obvious way of avoiding trademark infringement. However care should always be taken to make sure you do not go beyond the terms of the licence agreement. We would always suggest that a licence agreement is drafted by a specialist intellectual property solicitor.
Take steps to register your mark. The sooner the better as this will not only protect your brand from other third parties but may also be a defence to any future trademark infringement claim (see above).
Trademark holders often take swift action against infringers especially where they seek immediate injunctive relief which can be lost if there is a delay. A defendant will normally receive a strongly worded cease and desist letter which will likely insist on various undertakings being agreed in order to cure the infringement and avoid court proceedings being issued. If you do receive a cease and desist letter, do not ignore it. Specialist legal advice should be sought. There may be defences (see above) available which can head off a claim before it escalates.
There are a broad range of remedies available to a claimant if it is successful in proving trademark infringement. These include:
Our specialist intellectual property disputes team routinely advises on a broad range of disputes relating to trademarks along with other intellectual property disputes relating to copyright, patents, confidential information and data protection. The team is also highly skilled at advising on design rights and reputation management issues and are regularly instructed by clients from the arts, media, textile and clothing sectors in the UK and internationally. If you need advice on trademark or other intellectual property infringements, please do not hesitate to contact a member of the team today.