Manolete Partners Plc v Howarth: When Insolvency Claims Don't Succeed – Preferences and Transactions at an Undervalue

Vicky Biggs's profile picture

Vicky Biggs - Legal Director

Published

Types of insolvency processes

In the recent case of Manolete Partners Plc v Howarth, the court dismissed Manolete’s claim against the former CEO of a collapsed legal firm. 

In this blog, our Insolvency and Restructuring team explore the background to the case, the court’s decision and what the practical implications of the case are.

Contact Our Insolvency and Restructuring Team

What was the background?

One Legal Services Limited (the Company) was a legal aid practice operating as an alternative business structure (ABS).  The Company experienced severe financial distress from 2018 due to accumulated Crown debts, historic liabilities inherited from a prior acquisition, and chronic cash flow shortages. 

The Company’s CEO and director, Trevor Howarth, had earlier advanced a £75,000 loan to the Company.  Contractual interest was payable on the loan, so by early 2019 the amount payable by the Company to Mr Howarth stood at £97,445, plus further interest.

In August 2018, Mr Howarth sought specialist insolvency advice from Robert Adamson of Armstrong Watson and a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA) was suggested. 

The CVA was approved (with HMRC-imposed modifications) on 22 February 2019. 

Crucially, the CVA recorded Mr Howarth’s director’s loan as excluded – meaning that it was unaffected by the CVA and outside the CVA fund. 

Immediately after the approval of the CVA, Mr Adamson advised Mr Howarth to come off payroll to reduce PAYE/NIC liabilities and instead receive monthly director’s loan repayments equivalent to his net salary. 

Between April and December 2019, the Company paid Mr Howarth £101,000.  This was openly recorded in management accounts and visible to Armstrong Watson during their routine monitoring of the CVA.

The CVA failed, and the Company entered administration on 3 January 2020. 

After the death of Mr Adamson, Manolete were assigned the claim by the administrators and brought proceedings alleging that the payments of £101,000 to Mr Howarth constituted preferences and transactions at an undervalue pursuant to sections 239 and 238 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (the Act). 

Sign Up For More Legal Insights

validation order insolvency

The Court’s Decision

The court dismissed the entire application, holding that neither the preference claim nor the transaction at an undervalue claim was made out on the evidence. 

On the transaction at an undervalue claim, the court found that Manolete failed to prove that the Company entered into any transaction at an undervalue. 

The central flaw was the lack of documentary evidence supporting the assertion that Mr Howarth’s loan balance at the relevant time was only £89,159.68. 

Contemporaneous records, including the CVA statement of affairs, showed that Mr Howarth’s loan stood at £97,445 plus 8% interest, meaning that the £101,000 paid was broadly consistent with what was owed. 

Notwithstanding this, the court held that even if an undervalue had been established, Mr Howarth had a defence under section 238(5) of the Act i.e. that the Company acted in good faith, for the purpose of carrying on its business, and with reasonable grounds to believe the arrangement benefited the Company by reducing its PAYE/NIC liabilities. 

On the preference claim, the court held that there was “no preference in fact” because the payments of £101,000 simply replaced Mr Howarth’s salary and therefore Mr Howarth was not put in a better position and indeed received slightly less than his usual net pay. 

The statutory presumption of desire to prefer was plainly rebutted as the Company’s true motive was to conserve cash and follow the advice of Mr Adamson, the CVA supervisor. 

The court therefore concluded that Mr Howarth had acted responsibly, transparently and on professional advice. 

Get In Touch With Our Team

court decision

The Practical Implications of the Case

Whilst the court’s decision in this case was a major win for the director involved, it does provide helpful guidance for both office-holders and litigation funders who bring these types of claim. 

The case highlights the importance of contemporaneous documentation. 

The court was critical of the failure to preserve and disclose meeting notes, emails and working papers and said that missing documentation may justify the drawing of adverse inferences.  It is therefore vital that insolvency practitioners maintain records of advice given and decisions made. 

The court’s decision also confirms that directors may legitimately rely on the advice of insolvency professionals. 

Where a director acts transparently and honestly and in accordance with guidance from an office-holder (such as a CVA supervisor) they are less vulnerable to allegations later regarding preferences and transactions at an undervalue. 

This results in shifting the evidential burden back to the applicant to demonstrate wrongdoing with proper proof.  The court’s judgment also clarified that salary-for-loan swap arrangements may be valid and commercially justified when designed to reduce PAYE/NIC liabilities, particularly when they replace salary. 

The court also confirmed that those bringing claims must ensure that claims are properly investigated, factually sound and supported by documents before court proceedings are commenced. 

Speak To Our Team

The Process Restructuring Plans

Contact our Insolvency and Restructuring Team

Our Insolvency and Restructuring team has significant experience in insolvency litigation.  We act for both office-holders and litigation funders who bring claims and individuals who face such claims.

Please contact us today if you need assistance. 

0161 941 4000

Latest Myerson Insolvency & Restructuring News


Myerson Solicitors Strengthens Chambers UK Rankings with Six New Recognitions in 2027 Guide
News

Myerson Solicitors Strengthens Chambers UK Rankings with Six New Recognitions in 2027 Guide

Leading independent law firm Myerson Solicitors has secured six new rankings in the Chambers and Partners UK Guide 2027, further strengthening its reputation for legal excellence and reflecting a sustained period of growth and success for the firm.  

Read News
3 minutes reading time
Family Law | 15 October 2026
Insolvency Sale Transactions Under the Microscope
Webinar

Insolvency Sale Transactions Under the Microscope

Insolvency sale transactions are increasingly subject to scrutiny from creditors, regulators and the courts. For insolvency practitioners and restructuring professionals, understanding the legal, regulatory and practical challenges surrounding these transactions is essential. In this webinar, Myerson Solicitors' Insolvency & Restructuring...

Watch Webinar
55 minutes watch time
Insolvency & Restructuring | Updated 19 November 2026
Directors’ Duties: What Does Saxon Woods v Costa Mean for Company Directors?
Blog

Directors’ Duties: What Does Saxon Woods v Costa Mean for Company Directors?

The Supreme Court’s recent decision in Saxon Woods Investments Limited and others v Costa   provides important guidance on the limits of directors' duties under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006. In summary, the Supreme Court’s judgment confirms that a director cannot secretly pursue their own strategy contrary to the strategy agreed by the...

Read Blog
6 minutes reading time
Directors | 28 September 2026
Can a Court Save a Retailer? The TG Jones Judgment Shows the Limits of Restructuring
Blog

Can a Court Save a Retailer? The TG Jones Judgment Shows the Limits of Restructuring

On 1 July 2026, the High Court approved TG Jones' restructuring plan - but the judge (Mr Justice Hildyard) openly questioned whether the turnaround would succeed.  Our Insolvency and Restructuring team explore what the Court’s decision in this case tells us about the current restructuring regime in England and Wales. 

Read Blog
6 minutes reading time
Insolvency & Restructuring | 21 August 2026
Can a Foreign Judgment Be Used for a Bankruptcy Petition in England and Wales?
Blog

Can a Foreign Judgment Be Used for a Bankruptcy Petition in England and Wales?

Can a creditor petition for the bankruptcy of an individual in England and Wales on the basis of a foreign judgment that has never been recognised by the English courts? The Supreme Court's recent decision in Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC (In Liquidation in the Russian Federation) provides a definitive answer and has...

Read Blog
5 minutes reading time
Bankruptcy & IVAs | 17 August 2026
Myerson Magazine Summer 2026 Issue
Newsletter

Myerson Magazine Summer 2026 Issue

We're pleased to share the latest issue of Myerson Magazine, bringing together practical legal insights, updates on significant legislative changes and stories from across the firm. In this Summer edition, our experts explore the legal issues affecting individuals, families, business owners and property investors, from the Renters' Rights Act and...

Read Newsletter
30 minutes reading time
Gifting | 15 July 2026
Vicky Biggs's profile picture

Vicky Biggs

Legal Director

Vicky is a Legal Director in the Insolvency and Restructuring team at Myerson and has been with the firm since 2012. Utilising her commercial litigation experience, Vicky now specialises in contentious insolvency matters, advising insolvency practitioners, directors and individuals in relation to both corporate and personal insolvency issues.

Vicky advises on a wide range of insolvency matters, including claims made by administrators, liquidators and trustees in bankruptcy, director disqualification proceedings, remuneration approval applications, retention of title claims, validation orders, bankruptcy annulment applications and winding-up and bankruptcy petitions.

About Vicky Biggs