The Drowning Of Paula Leeson: Channel 5 Programme Set To Rediscover Tragic Case Of £4 Million Heiress Unlawfully Killed By Husband

Paula's family brought claims for unlawful killing, forfeiture and fraud against Mr McPherson. The forfeiture rule prevents a person from profiting from the estate of someone they have unlawfully killed. Whilst McPherson was cleared in the criminal court due to a lack of evidence, the civil court applies a lower burden of proof.

Mr Justice Smith found " without hesitation" that – on the balance of probabilities – McPherson had unlawfully caused Paula's death by compressing her neck in an armlock, rendering her unconscious and allowing her to drown.

Within his judgment, he concluded that "It is no exaggeration to say that lies and dishonesty pervade every aspect of [McPherson's] life. [McPherson] lies to anyone if it might serve his interests." He stated that he could not begin to comprehend the "pain and heartache that [Paula's] family has experienced as a result of Paula's death."

In relation to the Will upon which McPherson had forged a witness signature, Mr Justice Smith found the Will to be invalid due to the want of knowledge and approval.

He also found that Paula did not know or approve the contents of her purported Will, which is one of the requirements for a Will to be validly executed.

As a result of the High Court decision, McPherson, who Mr Smith found was " motivated by money", has forfeited any entitlement to Paula's assets, including the £3.9 million of insurance policies deceptively incepted by him.

The case appears to be the first forfeiture claim following an acquittal before the criminal courts and reinforces the principle that civil cases can sometimes succeed where criminal prosecutions fail, particularly in cases involving serious allegations such as unlawful killing.

Mr McPherson did not attend the civil proceedings and is believed to be residing in the South Pacific.

The case of Paula Leeson is a sobering reminder of the limitations of criminal proceedings and the critical role civil litigation can play in delivering justice where the higher burden of proof in criminal courts proves insurmountable.

While no legal outcome can undo the profound loss suffered by Paula's family, the High Court's decision ensures that her estate is protected.

The upcoming Channel 5 documentary will serve not only as a detailed retelling of the facts but also as a platform for raising awareness about the enduring importance of truth, accountability, and the pursuit of justice in all its forms.