When a company enters insolvent liquidation, its former directors may wish to preserve the goodwill, reputation and customer relationships built up over many years.
While establishing a new business following insolvency is not inherently problematic, strict restrictions apply where directors seek to continue trading under the same name as the insolvent company, or a name so similar that it may be mistaken for it.
Section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 imposes these restrictions to prevent so-called “phoenix” businesses from trading under the same or a similar name while leaving the original company's debts behind.
The recent High Court decision in English v Secretary of State for Business and Trade provides important guidance on the scope of one of the statutory exceptions to these restrictions. It also serves as a timely reminder that directors seeking to rely on an exception must ensure that its requirements are strictly satisfied.
In this article, our insolvency lawyers explain how section 216 works, the statutory exceptions available to former directors, and what the English decision means in practice.
Understanding Section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986: Why the Rule Exists
Section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 was introduced to address what is commonly known as the “phoenix syndrome”.
This arises where the business of a company that has entered insolvent liquidation is continued through a new entity operating under the same, or a sufficiently similar, name.
The concern is that the new business may benefit from the goodwill and reputation established by the original company, while leaving its debts and other liabilities behind.
The legislation seeks to prevent this practice and protect creditors and the wider public from being misled about the identity of the business with which they are dealing.
The restrictions apply to individuals who were directors or shadow directors of the insolvent company at any time during the 12 months ending with the day before its liquidation.
Unless a statutory exception applies, section 216 prohibits those individuals, for a period of five years from the date of liquidation, from:
- Acting as a director of another company using a prohibited name
- Being involved in the promotion, formation or management of a company using a prohibited name
- Carrying on a business under a prohibited name
Importantly, the restrictions are not confined to the use of a prohibited name by an incorporated company. They may also apply where an individual carries on a business under that name without incorporating a company.
What Is a Prohibited Name?
A name is prohibited if it is either the same name as the liquidated company or if it is so similar as to suggest an association with the company in liquidation.
In determining whether a name is sufficiently similar, the Court will consider the circumstances as a whole, including branding, trading activities, customer perception and the nature of the businesses concerned.
The prohibition therefore extends beyond a company's registered name and may also capture trading names.
The Consequences of Breaching Section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986
A breach of section 216 may lead to civil and/or criminal liability. Both civil and criminal liability are automatic: if the conditions for liability are met, the Court has no discretion to limit the defendant’s liability.
Infringement of section 216 can lead to:
- A fine and/or imprisonment
- Being disqualified from acting as a company director
- Proceedings for confiscation of any benefit obtained during the infringement
- Personal liability for all debts incurred in running the new business in contravention of section 216.
The Statutory Exceptions
Section 216 provides several exceptions to the general prohibition on reusing a prohibited company name.
These recognise that, in certain circumstances, continued use of the name may be commercially legitimate, provided the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
The exceptions are:
Acquisition of the Business from an Insolvency Office-Holder
Where the whole, or substantially the whole, of the insolvent company's business is acquired under qualifying arrangements involving an insolvency office-holder, a former director may be able to continue using a prohibited name provided that the new company gives notice to all the creditors of the insolvent company.
Obtaining the Court’s Permission
Any person to whom the prohibition applies can apply to the Court for leave to act in a way that is prohibited by section 216. The application must be made to the Court within 7 days of the original company going into liquidation and leave must be granted by the Court no later than 6 weeks after the company went into liquidation.
Existing Use by Another Company
The last exception is where the second company that has a prohibited name has been known by that prohibited name for at least 12 months before the insolvent company went into liquidation. The second company must not have been dormant at any time in those 12 months. This exception only applies to limited liability companies, not to unincorporated businesses such as sole traders and partnerships.
It was the scope of this third exception that came under scrutiny in the case of English v Secretary of State for Business and Trade.
The Facts of English v Secretary of State for Business and Trade
Mr English had traded as a sole trader under the name "Insignia Shade and Shutter Company" since 1997.
In 2000, he incorporated Insignia Blind Co Ltd and became its director. Although the company traded using the "Insignia" branding, the trading name and logo remained Mr English's personal property and were never formally transferred to the company.
On 22 January 2020, Insignia Blind Co Ltd entered insolvent liquidation.
Following the liquidation, Mr English continued to trade as a sole trader using the following names:
- Insignia Shade and Shutter Company
- Insignia Blind Services
- Insignia
The Insolvency Service considered this to be a breach of section 216 and warned Mr English accordingly. Despite these warnings, he continued to trade under these names.
Mr English was subsequently prosecuted and convicted. He received a conditional discharge and was disqualified from acting as a director for three years.
He subsequently appealed to the High Court, challenging his conviction.
The Legal Issue
The appeal centred on the interpretation of Rule 22.7 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016.
As set out above, this rule provides an exception where a company using a prohibited name has been known by that name throughout the 12 months preceding the liquidation and has not been dormant during that period.
Mr English argued that the rule should be interpreted broadly enough to extend beyond companies and encompass sole traders who had genuinely and continuously traded under the name before the company entered liquidation.
In essence, his position was that because he had traded as Insignia Shade and Shutter Company long before the incorporation of Insignia Blind Co Ltd, he ought to benefit from the exception.
The High Court's Decision
The High Court dismissed Mr English’s appeal.
The Court held that the wording of Rule 22.7 was clear and should be given its ordinary meaning. The rule expressly refers to a “company” and incorporates the Companies Act 2006 concept of corporate dormancy.
The Court concluded that there was no basis for extending the exception to sole traders or other unincorporated businesses.
The decision demonstrates the Court's reluctance to expand statutory exceptions beyond their express wording, particularly in a regulatory context designed to protect the public.
The judgment emphasises that where Parliament intended section 216 to extend to both incorporated and unincorporated businesses, it said so expressly.
By contrast, Rule 22.7 refers specifically to companies, indicating a deliberate legislative distinction. Importantly, the judgment also recognised that individuals are not without recourse. A former director who wishes to continue using a prohibited name may still apply to the Court for permission.
Practical Implications
The judgment in the English case provides useful clarification on the scope of section 216 and highlights several key considerations for directors and business owners.
In particular, the Court’s decision in the English case:
- Underlines the importance of understanding the limits of the statutory exceptions before continuing to trade under a prohibited name following an insolvent liquidation.
- Reinforces that the statutory exceptions to section 216 will not be extended beyond their express wording. Directors seeking to rely on an exception must therefore ensure that all the relevant statutory requirements are satisfied.
- Confirms that longstanding use of a trading name as a sole trader does not bring an individual within the exception set out in Rule 22.7. Even where a person used a business name for many years before incorporating a company, that historical use alone will not permit them to continue using the name following the company's insolvent liquidation.
- Confirms that ownership of a trading name does not provide protection. Mr English’s personal ownership of the trading name and logo did not exempt him from the restrictions imposed by section 216. The Court confirmed that ownership of intellectual property rights and compliance with statutory restrictions are separate matters. Directors should therefore not assume that personally owning a trading name or brand will protect them from the consequences of reusing a prohibited name following an insolvent liquidation.
Conclusion
The High Court’s decision in English v Secretary of State for Business and Trade highlights the continuing importance of section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986 and the limits of its statutory exceptions.
The Court confirmed that the exception under Rule 22.7 is confined to companies and cannot be extended to sole traders or other unincorporated businesses, regardless of how long they have traded under the relevant name. The decision reinforces the importance of interpreting the statutory exceptions in accordance with their express wording.
For directors, the message is clear: the restrictions on reusing a prohibited name must be carefully considered before a new company begins to trade.
Obtaining specialist legal advice at an early stage can help avoid potentially serious consequences, including criminal sanctions and personal liability for business debts.
Contact Our Insolvency Solicitors
Please do not hesitate to contact Myerson’s experienced and knowledgeable Insolvency & Restructuring Team if you need assistance or advice on issues relating to section 216 of the Insolvency Act 1986.
01619414000
Latest Myerson Insolvency & Restructuring News
Myerson Solicitors Strengthens Chambers UK Rankings with Six New Recognitions in 2027 Guide
Leading independent law firm Myerson Solicitors has secured six new rankings in the Chambers and Partners UK Guide 2027, further strengthening its reputation for legal excellence and reflecting a sustained period of growth and success for the firm.
Read NewsInsolvency Sale Transactions Under the Microscope
Insolvency sale transactions are increasingly subject to scrutiny from creditors, regulators and the courts. For insolvency practitioners and restructuring professionals, understanding the legal, regulatory and practical challenges surrounding these transactions is essential. In this webinar, Myerson Solicitors' Insolvency & Restructuring...
Watch Webinar
Directors’ Duties: What Does Saxon Woods v Costa Mean for Company Directors?
The Supreme Court’s recent decision in Saxon Woods Investments Limited and others v Costa provides important guidance on the limits of directors' duties under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006. In summary, the Supreme Court’s judgment confirms that a director cannot secretly pursue their own strategy contrary to the strategy agreed by the...
Read Blog
Can a Court Save a Retailer? The TG Jones Judgment Shows the Limits of Restructuring
On 1 July 2026, the High Court approved TG Jones' restructuring plan - but the judge (Mr Justice Hildyard) openly questioned whether the turnaround would succeed. Our Insolvency and Restructuring team explore what the Court’s decision in this case tells us about the current restructuring regime in England and Wales.
Read Blog
Can a Foreign Judgment Be Used for a Bankruptcy Petition in England and Wales?
Can a creditor petition for the bankruptcy of an individual in England and Wales on the basis of a foreign judgment that has never been recognised by the English courts? The Supreme Court's recent decision in Valeriy Ernestovich Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC (In Liquidation in the Russian Federation) provides a definitive answer and has...
Read Blog