Although a prenuptial agreement sets out the parties’ intentions on a divorce, the agreements are not legally binding and so the court retains its ultimate discretion to determine the distribution of the assets on divorce.
However, the existence and contents of a prenuptial agreement must be taken into account by the court when the court considers financial remedy proceedings.
The influence and weight of a prenuptial agreement therefore depends on the circumstances of the case and also the circumstances at the time the prenup was entered into.
This is an important protection as there is the possibility that a prenuptial agreement has been entered into without one party’s full intentions or without fully understanding the agreement they are entering into.
The court would then take this into account when considering how much to rely on the provisions of the prenup.
In the case of Radmacher v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42 the Supreme Court held that: “the court should give effect to a nuptial agreement that is freely entered into by each party with a full appreciation of its implications unless in the circumstances prevailing it would not be fair to hold the parties to the agreement”.
Provided that test is met, the court will give effect to a prenuptial agreement.
In simpler terms this means that the following will be considered by the court:
- whether the prenuptial agreement was entered into by each party of their own free will, without undue influence or pressure;
- the emotional and mental wellbeing of each party and their age, maturity and previous experience of long-term relationships;
- whether the marriage would still have proceeded without a prenuptial agreement in place;
- whether at the time of signing, both parties were in possession of all the information material to their decision to sign the agreement. This doesn’t necessarily mean that both parties were aware of all the assets and income of the other, but that both parties knew what they were entering into;
- whether both parties obtained independent legal advice before signing the prenuptial agreement
- the length of the marriage and the length of time since the prenuptial agreement was signed; or
- the current financial needs and position of both parties.