Minority shareholders can often have less power over the management of the company. This can lead to disputes between shareholders particularly where their relationship breaks down.

The classic litigation process for resolving shareholder disputes is the unfair prejudice petition under Section 994 of the Companies Act. This is typically brought by a minority shareholder in circumstances where the company’s affairs have been or are being conducted in a manner that is unfairly prejudicial to the interest of all or some of the members of the company.

Unfairly prejudicial conduct

For conduct to be unfairly prejudicial it must cause prejudice or harm to an interest of some or all of the members of the company and it must be unfair. Examples of unfairly prejudicial conduct are:

  • Failure to pay dividends to the shareholders;
    • Exclusion from management where there is a justified expectation of involvement;
    • Breaches of the articles of association;
    • Majority shareholders awarding themselves excessive remuneration; and
    • Inequitable conduct.

The petitioner must demonstrate that they are worse off as a result of the conduct. The Court will take into account the legitimate expectations of the shareholder to define the parameters of the unfairly prejudicial conduct – for instance the rules in the articles of association or whether a “quasi-partnership” exists.  

Remedies

The Court has a very wide discretion to grant relief where unfair prejudice is found. The most common relief sought and granted is the purchase of shares which allows a “clean break” between the shareholders who can no longer work together.  Other orders that the Court can make include:

• Regulate the conduct of the company’s affairs in the future;
• Require the company to refrain from or carry out an act;
• Authorise civil proceedings to be brought in the name of the company; and
• Prohibit the company from making changes to the articles of association.

The Legal 500

Our commercial litigation department is ranked "Top-Tier" by the Legal 500. 

"The ‘dynamic, positive, forward-thinking, effective and tenacious’ team at Myerson Solicitors LLP gives ‘sound and sensible legal advice’ and is ‘very client-friendly’. It handles general commercial litigation including shareholder disputes and professional negligence, in addition to contentious trusts and probate, IP, banking and property litigation and commercial agency matters."

Meet Our Specialists

Home-grown or recruited from national, regional or City firms. Our specialists are experts in their fields and respected by their peers.

Adam Maher

Adam Maher

Adam is a Partner and is Head of our Commercial Litigation department

Philip Ball

Philip Ball

Philip is a Senior Solicitor in our Corporate Commercial department

Tim Norman

Tim Norman

Tim is a Senior Partner in our Commercial Litigation department

Suzanne Carr

Suzanne Carr

Suzanne is a Senior Solicitor in Myerson’s Dispute Resolution team

Contact Us

Book your consultation using the below enquiry form, alternatively, you can call us on

0161-941-4000